• About
  • Profiles
  • Projects
  • Publications
Beyond Market Prices

mobile phones in trade and livelihood activities – Ghana, Uganda, India, China

  • About
  • Profiles
  • Projects
  • Publications

The Myth of Market Price Information: A Working Paper

Posted on March 8, 2013 by Jenna Burrell

Our first comparative case bringing together findings from fieldwork (by Jenna Burrell and Elisa Oreglia) among rural farmers in Hebei and Shandong provinces in China and fishermen and fish traders at Lake Victoria and Lake Kyoga in Uganda. The working paper is titled “The Myth of Market Price Information: Mobile Phones and Epistemology in ICTD.”

A brief summary of the paper is below:

The notion that farmers use mobile phones to acquire market price information has become a kind of shorthand for the potential of this technology to empower rural, low-income populations in the Global South. We argue that the envisioned consequences of ‘market price information’ to market efficiency with benefits at all income levels is a kind of myth. This myth frequently promulgated by mass media outlets such as the Economist, is also the subject of serious discussion among scholars. The idea has become a kind of boundary object recast within the epistemic cultures of economics, computer science, policy work, and development expertise. We draw from our ethnographic work (among rural agriculturalists in China and Uganda) to offer four alternatives to this myth.

We propose the following four assertions countering this myth, that:

(1) information on prices is not necessarily scarce
(2) market prices are often irrelevant or subordinate to other factors in trade related decision-making
(3) improvements in market efficiency realized by the mobile phone may not stem from the better circulation of market prices
(4) obtaining market prices is often not the most valued application of the mobile phone in trade

For further details please download the paper.

This entry was posted in Farming, Fishing, Market Information Systems. Bookmark the permalink

Click here to cancel reply.

Add Your Comment

Your email will not be published.

  • Recent Posts

    • Scarcity of Space in the Market
    • How to support smallholder and women farmers with ICT4Ag
    • What do RCTs of Market Information Systems actually evaluate?
    • The ‘Myth of Market Price Information’ at the CRS ICT4D conference
    • Chris Foster on ‘Thinking about market information systems’ in Rwanda’s tea sector
  • Recent Comments

    • Archives

      • July 2015
      • June 2015
      • May 2015
      • April 2015
      • September 2014
      • May 2014
      • December 2013
      • April 2013
      • March 2013
      • February 2013
      • January 2013
      • December 2012
      • November 2012
      • October 2012
      • September 2012
      • August 2012
    • Categories

      • Farming
      • Field Notes
      • Fishing
      • Infographics
      • M-Banking
      • Market Information Systems
      • Market Women
      • Other Market Actors
      • Uncategorized
    • Meta

      • Register
      • Log in
      • Entries feed
      • Comments feed
      • WordPress.org
    • Connect with us:
    • RSS
    • © 2021 A Project at the UC-Berkeley School of Information
    • Powered by WordPress